How a local discussion on Homely sparked a national debate about Australia’s education

What began as a simple question posted on Homely—”What is the best school in Melbourne?”—has ignited a nationwide conversation about the state of education in Australia. A single query from a concerned parent led to a debate that saw voices from across the country weigh in on the pressing issue of public versus private schooling.

A simple question. A national conversation.

The conversation kicked off in Kew, a leafy suburb known for its prestigious schools. A user on Homely, one of Australia’s favourite property portals and lifestyle platforms, asked for recommendations on the best schools in the area. Initially, the thread was filled with suggestions for elite private institutions like Xavier College, Trinity and Methodist Ladies’ College. However, the topic quickly evolved, touching on broader questions of educational equality, school funding, and the role of public schools in shaping future generations.

Public vs. private: a heated debate ensues.

As more people joined the discussion, so did the range of opinions. Some participants championed the high standards of private schools, while others passionately defended the virtues of public education. One parent wrote, “It’s not just about facilities. Public schools offer life skills and a sense of community that private schools can’t replicate.” Another responded, “Private schools prepare our children for the competitive world—they offer the best opportunities.”

Before long, the discussion moved beyond Melbourne, drawing in users from Perth to Sydney. It became a platform where Australians voiced their opinions on how best to prepare the next generation for success. 

A reflection of larger social questions about schooling in Australia

As the debate grew, it raised larger questions about the fairness of comparing public and private institutions. Many users pointed out the wide disparity in funding and resources, with one commenter saying, “We need to improve education for all students, not just those in elite schools.” The conversation touched on government reforms, funding equity, and stories of personal experiences—like one user who shared how their child thrived in a rural public school, while other rural families enquiring about Geelong Grammar’s boarding routine. “Proximity should not be under-rated in the choice of school: there is a big difference in location between Grimwade and Carey, for example.” says one user. “At Junior level you will pay the price of distance doing drop offs and pickups, at senior level your children will do so with public transport routes. Closer is better, in my book.”

Single sex vs co-ed was a hot topic 

“Gotta wonder about single sex schools. Does it really prepare them for real life?” asks one user, resulting in interesting discussions about the pros and cons of single vs co-ed. Homely user Maggie, said, “I am now turning back to single sex school for my boy and girl. I live at Hartwell (Camberwell) and am very impressed by Strathcona. Do you or anyone in the forum have any insight of this school? Thanks for all open discussions on this forum.”

The rumour that rocked the thread

The discussion even uncovered a concerning rumour about what goes on in our schools. Homely user, Prue, who lives in New York asked, “Our family are moving from New York ( with 1 boy and 2 girls) . We want our children to attend the best schools and are looking at private schools. We have been impressed by a number…however a friend of mine said something quite shocking to me about independent schools in Melbourne. She said that some of these schools still practice corporal punishment!”

Our multifaceted education system 

The debate highlighted a range of topics, from the importance of diversity in schools to the role of technology in modern education. It raised critical questions about ensuring equal access to high-quality education for all children, regardless of background or location.

“I read somewhere that if you invested the private school fees for 30 years you could buy a house with the compound interest! Imagine if you gave your kids the option – work hard in a public school and I’ll give you cash of 500k at the end or private school?, “ asks one user. 

Now that might be a better life lesson.”

The Power of Community on Homely

“Our community on Homely thrives because of the genuine, organic conversations that happen every day,” said Homely’s Co-Founder and Co-CEO Jason Spencer.

“We’re proud to provide a platform where Australians can openly share their experiences and opinions, reflecting the true diversity of perspectives in our society. The level of engagement we see, especially in debates like the one on education, shows just how deeply people care about the issues that shape their lives and communities. It’s this authentic, grassroots connection that sets Homely apart.”

This viral discussion is a testament to the power of Homely’s community. While Homely is known for its property listings, it’s also a platform where Australians connect and engage in meaningful conversations about what matters most in their communities. 

This debate on schooling is just one example of how Homely brings real people together to discuss real issues.

To read the full conversation and join the discussion, visit Homely’s discussion forum.