I have toured both Trinity Catholic School and Yarra PS in 2015. Although quite different from each other, I was impressed with both. Trinity is has newer clean buildings, classes looked orderly, structured and formal whereas Yarra is has older colourful buildings, classes looked freestyle and informal (first name bases with teachers). We went with Yarra PS to suit my child but I would have preferred Trinity. I have heard great things about Richmond West PS and also Richmond PS from parents at the playgrounds.